Review

Hell or High Water (2016)

Two men posing by an old car with bullet holes on the window, set in an open field under a partly cloudy sky. This is a scene from the 2016 film Hell or High Water starring Chris Pine and Ben Foster.
Two men posing by an old car with bullet holes on the window, set in an open field under a partly cloudy sky. This is a scene from the 2016 film Hell or High Water starring Chris Pine and Ben Foster.

image: Lionsgate

Director: David Mackenzie

Writer: Taylor Sheridan

Cast: Jeff Bridges, Chris Pine, Ben Foster, Gil Birmingham, Dale Dickey, Katy Mixon, Marin Ireland, Kevin Rankin

Run Time: 1h 42m

UK Rating: 15

8/10

n the 2010s there was a series of films about the effects of the most recent financial crash which ravaged rural communities with ruin and deprivation as the entire economy around sub prime lending collapsed. British director David Mackenzie directs this very American crime drama based on a script by Taylor Sheridan that proudly wears its cinematic and literary influences on its sleeve. Angry and violent but also thoughtful and elegiac. Hell or High Water is in the vein of Cormac McCarthy and Elmore Leonard, writers who saw the nobility in desperate criminals and law men. Whilst also being deeply in debt to 70s crime thrillers like The Friends of Eddie Coyle (1973) and Thunderbolt and Lightfoot (1974), which stars a younger Jeff Bridges.

Hell or High Water centres around brothers, Tanner (Ben Foster) and Toby (Chris Pine) reunited after the death of their mother. Together they begin a spate of robberies targeting the bank that foreclosed on their family property. They're only stealing the untraceable bills from the counter rather than taking the riskier but more lucrative cash in the vault. Their aim is to steal enough money to buy back the farm and ensure Toby's sons can profit from the oil he's discovered on the land. Tanner (played with impulsive recklessness by Ben Foster) has just returned after serving a ten year prison sentence and sits in stark contrast to his patient and intelligent brother. Toby is only doing this for the benefit his children and balks at the violence required. They're doggedly pursued by Texas Rangers Marcus Hamilton (Jeff Bridges) and Alberto Parker (Gil Birmingham). True to type Hamilton is on the verge of retirement and the pair bicker endlessly as they muse on his career. There's parallels between the brothers and the two Rangers in the way the men interact, their conversations peppered with near constant childish insults. Hamilton is ornery and occasionally outright racist to his (clearly long suffering) partner but is clearly good police and very quickly spots the patterns that will lead them all to a surely violent showdown. 

Two men wearing cowboy hats sitting at outdoor tables, one in a gray shirt and the other in a white shirt. This is a scene from the 2016 fil Hell or High Water starring Ben foster and Chris Pine.
Two men wearing cowboy hats sitting at outdoor tables, one in a gray shirt and the other in a white shirt. This is a scene from the 2016 fil Hell or High Water starring Ben foster and Chris Pine.

image: Lionsgate

The film makes no allusions to who it thinks the real villains are in its narrative. Like Andrew Dominik’s Killing Them Softly (2012), the film’s main flaw is the lack of subtlety in conveying the culpability of the banking sector in the financial crisis. It was their greed that caused it and there was no bailout for the people whose lives were ruined in the resulting crash. Hell or High Water makes this clear during the film's opening moments (graffiti on the first bank reads “3 tours in Iraq but no bailout for people like us”) and is reinforced with nearly every interaction in the film. This is all delivered with such vitriol and righteous anger (especially from the excellent Katie Mixon as a waitress unwilling to hand over her generous tip from Toby to the rangers) that you're willing to overlook a lack of subtlety. This anger simmers steadily but reaches boiling point in the film's second half where it begins to erupt as the net begins to tighten around the brothers.

Praise was deservedly heaped upon Jeff Bridges for his role (he received a best supporting actor nomination) as the Ranger tracking the criminals. While he teases his partner relentlessly he’s also empathetic with the public, treating each witness with paternal care. There’s shades of his performance as Rooster Cogburn in the Coen’s True Grit (2010) in Hamilton’s almost incomprehensible Texas drawl. Chris Pine was only available to shoot for two weeks in a brief break whilst filming Star Trek: Beyond (2016), it's easily his finest performance. You get the sense that Toby was the pragmatic mediator in the family able to navigate warring personalities, more patient and cool headed than his brother. There’s none of the insouciant charm Pine employs in the Star Trek films and while he’s not as quick to temper as Tanner that same violence is still bubbling under the surface. Ben Foster’s Tanner is a creature of pure id, governed by a deep seated need to prove himself, he is twitchy and garrulous but clearly damaged by a difficult life and his time inside. It’s a shame that Gil Birmingham’s Parker isn't fleshed out a little more, he’s given little to do besides react to the boisterous Hamilton though still he makes do and gives as good as he gets.

Two men in casual clothes in a rural setting, one leaning on a fence post and the other sitting on the tailgate of a weathered pickup truck, with a windmill and a cloudy sky in the background. Still from the film Hell or High Water.
Two men in casual clothes in a rural setting, one leaning on a fence post and the other sitting on the tailgate of a weathered pickup truck, with a windmill and a cloudy sky in the background. Still from the film Hell or High Water.

image: Lionsgate

Despite the contemporary setting Hell of High Water is a western, a film of clear allegiances and harsh lessons. The brother's criminality is out of step with modernity (witnesses are perplexed by the very idea of robbing banks) and neither of them seem to see the future stretching out too far ahead. This fatalism is informed by their environment, run down and desolate towns picked clean by the system that they're intending to rob. Every billboard they pass as they drive through deserted towns and down empty roads is advertising predatory payday loans. There's beauty in this emptiness too, particularly in the wide expanses bereft of civilisation, a fact that Jeff Bridges’ character remarks on as he and his partner drive a hill overlooking endless green pastures. There's a great sense of the enormity of the Texas landscape (despite being shot in New Mexico) with John Ford like photography capturing the massive skies over empty farms which is all attractively shot by Giles Nuttgens. It’s best when accompanied by Warren Ellis and Nick Cave’s score which is wistful and at times evokes Carter Burwell’s Fargo (1996) score, it’s a shame it’s a little overpowered by an overuse of too on the nose licensed music throughout.

Hell or High Water walks a fine line between excess and restraint but mostly pulls it off. There’s bound to be some left frustrated by the ending which leaves some things deliberately unresolved but this ambiguity feels natural considering the film's themes and influences. The film doesn’t stick around long enough to really dig into some of the issues that it raises but the anger that runs through it will be felt long after the credits roll.

Watched on Blu-ray

Published 20th August 2026